Bonfire lit despite concerns about asbestos

A bonfire on a site that contains asbestos was set alight despite warnings over the dangers of doing so.

Northern Irelands environment minister had urged people not to light or attend the bonfire in south Belfast on Friday night.

Andrew Muir has defended the Northern Ireland Environment Agencys (NIEA) handling of removing the material, accusing political opponents of "finger pointing".

Concerns had been raised about asbestos at the site as well as fears over the power supply to two major hospitals because the bonfire is near an electricity substation.

The NIEA had removed about 20kg of asbestos from the site, between the Donegall Road and the Westlink, and had confirmed that further fragments of asbestos had been found at the site.

Speaking for the first time about the matter, Muir, an Alliance Party assembly member, said: "There are many ways to celebrate but not at this site.

"Personally I respect how important the Eleventh and Twelfth is, I understand its importance but Id plead with people to exercise caution and not to light this bonfire if they could."

Muir told BBC News NI he was first made aware of the issues at this bonfire site a "number of weeks ago".

Bonfires are lit as part of Eleventh night celebrations in some unionist areas, to usher in the Twelfth of July.

The Twelfth commemorates the Battle of the Boyne in 1690 when the Protestant King William III - also known as King Billy and William of Orange - defeated Catholic King James II.

Speaking about the Meridi Street bonfire, the grand secretary of the Orange Order, Rev Mervyn Gibson, said if asbestos had been a major issue, environmental agencies should have said so months ago, as bonfire builders had been on site since January.

Mr Gibson told the BBCs Good Morning Ulster Programme that people should "go and enjoy themselves" at the bonfire.

"Its clear for everybody that the decision that was made was a political decision. This asbestos has been there from 2017," he said.

"I believe the council voted a couple of weeks ago for the bonfire to go ahead. A few days before it then Sinn Féin and Alliance and the SDLP decide to vote against it."

However, former Progressive Unionist Party (PUP) leader Brian Ervine said the bonfire should not be lit.

Speaking on BBC Radio Ulsters Talkback programme, he said: "It would be preferable if they did not light the bonfire, but if they do light the bonfire then they must be prepared for the consequences that follow for themselves and their people."

He also said that after 12 July, "all the executive and all the agencies have to clear the site and make it safe".

Sinn Féin assembly member Pat Sheehan said "serious public safety concerns remain".

"A factual assessment is urgently needed to determine the extent of asbestos on this site and the dangers it presents."

He added that "lessons need to be learned" over how "we ended up in this position".

On Thursday, police confirmed they would not assist in the removal of the bonfire.

They had been asked by Belfast City Council to assist contractors to dismantle the bonfire before it was lit.

The PSNI said that, after a multi-agency meeting, it was felt "the risk of the bonfire proceeding as planned was lower and more manageable than the intervention of contractors and the proposed methodology of dismantling it".

Last week, the council voted to write to the environment minister to have the asbestos removed, said it remained concerned about asbestos on the site and would continue to raise concerns with the NIEA.

The NIEA said it was first alerted to the issues around the bonfire on 16 May, but "circumstances did not allow for the safe and controlled removal of the asbestos", prior to the Eleventh.

It said mitigating measures were agreed to reduce the risk to public health.

Democratic Unionist Party (DUP) councillor Sarah Bunting questioned the NIEA finding more suspected asbestos.

"The sites we were shown where the asbestos has been found, most of them were just around the stockpile of asbestos that has been covered… why was that not found before?"

Bonfire builders have voluntarily removed tiers of pallets from the top of the bonfire and told BBC News NI the action was an "olive branch" to those concerned.

Alan Stout, a GP and the chair of the BMA NI Council, said it was "surreal" that people could have been exposed to asbestos at the site.

"If theres asbestos there just dont go there, any other circumstance, environment... be it a school be it a hospital, you rope it off, you secure it and you remove it in a safe manner and... you do not expose your general population to it."

Dr Stout said people should not attend the bonfire and should not be near the site.

The landowners, Boron Developments, bought the site in the summer of 2017 and were made aware of asbestos at that time.

Boron Developments have said it engaged a waste management company to remove the asbestos but the company needed "no personnel" on the site in order to complete the removal of asbestos.

Due to people "bringing in materials and building the bonfire" the company told the landowners it could not complete its work.

The council said while the lands at the site remained "the responsibility of the landowner" the council and the NIEA were "working together in relation to this site".