Tesla found partly to blame for fatal Autopilot crash

A jury in Florida has found Tesla partly liable for a 2019 crash in which a Model S sedan using self-driving software killed a pedestrian and severely injured another.

Plaintiffs had argued the assistance software, called Autopilot, should have alerted the driver and activated the brakes before the crash.

Tesla had maintained the driver, George McGee, was at fault and called the verdict "wrong" in a statement to the BBC, while vowing to appeal. The result means the company will have to pay as much as $243m (£189m) in punitive and compensatory damages.

The verdict marks a setback for Tesla and CEO Elon Musk, who has touted self-driving technology as critical to the companys future.

Shares of Tesla dipped following the news and were nearly 2% lower when US markets closed.

Following the verdict, plaintiffs attorneys said Mr Musk had misrepresented the capabilities of the companys Autopilot driver assistance software.

"Tesla designed Autopilot only for controlled-access highways yet deliberately chose not to restrict drivers from using it elsewhere, alongside Elon Musk telling the world Autopilot drove better than humans," said attorney Brett Schreiber in a statement to the BBC.

Mr Schreiber said Tesla and Mr Musk had long propped up the companys valuation with "self-driving hype at the expense of human lives."

"Teslas lies turned our roads into test tracks for their fundamentally flawed technology," he added.

The company was sued by the family of Naibel Benavides Leon, 22, who was killed when she was struck by the Model S at a T-intersection in the Florida Keys in 2019. Her boyfriend Dillon Angulo suffered life-long injuries and was also involved in the suit.

The court heard the driver, Mr McGee, lost sight of the road when he dropped his phone as he was approaching the intersection, causing his car to continue through it and crash into an SUV parked on the other side. The two victims were standing nearby.

Neither Mr McGee, nor the Autopilot software, hit the brakes in time to prevent the crash.

After a three-week trial, the jury awarded $329m in total damages, including $129m in compensatory damages and $200m in punitive damages aimed at deterring Tesla from harmful behaviour in the future.

Tesla will be responsible for paying one-third of compensatory damages - $42.5m - and the entirety of the $200m in punitive damages, but according to the company, punitive damages are likely to be capped at a lesser amount.

"Todays verdict is wrong and only works to set back automotive safety and jeopardize Teslas and the entire industrys efforts to develop and implement life-saving technology," Tesla said in a statement.

Tesla said evidence at the trial showed the driver was solely at fault because he was speeding with his foot on the accelerator, which overrode Autopilot, while looking for his phone and not at the road.

"To be clear, no car in 2019, and none today, would have prevented this crash," Tesla said. "This was never about Autopilot; it was a fiction concocted by plaintiffs lawyers blaming the car when the driver – from day one – admitted and accepted responsibility."

While there have been other federal lawsuits involving Autopilot during fatal crashes, the Florida case that culminated on Friday was the first federal one to go to a jury.

Last year, Tesla settled a lawsuit over a 2018 crash that killed an Apple engineer after his Model X collided with a highway barrier while operating the companys Autopilot software.

In 2023, a California state jury found Tesla was not at fault in a case in which it was alleged that Autopilot had led to a death.

At trial, Mr McGee said his concept of Teslas Autopilot was that "it would assist me should I have a failure" or "make a mistake," and that he felt the software had failed him.

Mr McGee has settled a separate lawsuit with the plaintiffs for an undisclosed sum.

Tesla has long faced scrutiny over its Autopilot and self-driving technology, and critics hailed the jurys decision.

"Tesla is finally being held accountable for its defective designs and grossly negligent engineering practices," said Missy Cummings, a robotics professor at George Mason University.

The verdict comes as Tesla is battling weakening sales stemming in part from Mr Musks political activities.

Sign up for our Tech Decoded newsletter to follow the worlds top tech stories and trends. Outside the UK? Sign up here.