They stole the game - electronic line call fails at Wimbledon

This video can not be played

Kartal wins controversial game after electronic line-calling system fails

Anastasia Pavlyuchenkova said a game was stolen from her when Wimbledons electronic line-calling system failed during her fourth-round match against Britains Sonay Kartal.

There was no out call when a Kartal backhand went long at 4-4 in the first set, with chair umpire Nico Helwerth halting play.

Russian Pavlyuchenkova had seen the ball was out - and a TV replay showed that was the case by some distance.

Addressing the crowd, Helwerth said: "Were just going to check if the system was up and running, because there was no audio call."

After a telephone call, he announced the electronic system "was unfortunately unable to track the last point" and ordered the point to be replayed.

The rulebook states that if the electronic line calling system fails to make a call, "the call shall be made by the chair umpire".

It adds: "If the chair umpire is unable to determine if the ball was in or out, then the point shall be replayed. This protocol applies only to point-ending shots or in the case when a player stops play."

Had the ball been called out, Pavlyuchenkova would have won the point and taken the lead.

Instead, it was replayed, Kartal won the point and went on to break for a 5-4 lead.

The fact Pavlyuchenkova went on to win the match meant the malfunction was not as costly as it could have been, although she still questioned why the umpire did not call it out.

"Thats why hes there," she said. "He also saw it out, he told me after the match.

"I thought he would do that, but he didnt. Instead they just said replay.

"I dont know if its something to do [with Kartal being] local.

"I think its also difficult for him. He probably was scared to take such a big decision."

The electronic line-calling system did not call the shot from Sonay Kartal out

Pavlyuchenkova was clearly frustrated when she returned to her chair at the end of the game.

She told the umpire: "I dont know if its in or out. How do I know? How can you prove it?

"You took the game away from me ... They stole the game from me. They stole it."

A spokesperson for the All England Club said: "Due to operator error the system was deactivated on the point in question.

"The chair umpire followed the established process."

The automated line-calling system was introduced at Wimbledon for the first time this year.

Debbie Jevans - chair of the All England Club - said on Friday she was confident in its accuracy and the decision to bring it in.

The umpire explained to the players there had been no line call

Electronic line-calling technology has been under scrutiny this week at Wimbledon, with a number of players saying they do not trust it.

Such an obvious failure on the biggest stage - on Centre Court, in a match featuring a British player - has ensured this topic will not go away.

Britains Emma Raducanu has been one of those to voice concerns, saying some of the calls had been "dodgy", while former Olympic champion Belinda Bencic said the technology was a topic of discussion among players in the locker room.

Bencic said she was usually a fan of the technology but "it is not correct" at this tournament.

Line judges have been replaced by technology at many top-level tournaments, including the US Open and Australian Open.

Jevans previously said the technology was brought in because "the players wanted it" and some have backed the system, with former world number one Iga Swiatek saying she has had doubts but "has to trust" the calls.

When there were line judges, players could challenge the calls by using an electronic review. There are no challenges under the current system and video replays are not used.

Pavlyuchenkova suggested tennis should use video checks like football does "so that we can review the point".

"On such a big event I think it is necessary, since this isnt the first time this has happened," she told BBC Sport.

She said umpires were there to make big decisions otherwise they could "just play without them", adding: "I think the chair umpire should be able to take initiatives.

"Thats what he is there for and thats why he is sitting in that chair, otherwise I think we could have also had a match without a chair umpire.

"They have no problem giving us fines and code violations, for any reason sometimes. So I would like them to be a bit more intensive to this sort of situation."

Pavlyuchenkova added in a news conference: "I would prefer they looked at the lines and call in the errors [and] mistakes better."

Additional reporting by BBC sports news correspondent Laura Scott

This video can not be played

How Pavlyuchenkovas incredible mental toughness overcame glaring error

Wimbledon 2025

30 June to 13 July

Live across BBC TV, radio and online with extensive coverage on BBC iPlayer, Red Button, Connected TVs and mobile app.